American Primeval is a brutal historical western with a feminine heart

by | Jan 22, 2025 | All, Reviews

Last year Shogun blew away critics and audiences with its brutal highlighting of Japanese culture in the 16th century. It showed the world through the eyes of a newcomer caught up in a land, and power, grab between warring lords, driven by religion and greed. It was moving, bleak and beautiful, and an incredibly eye-opening story. This year, Netflix’s American Primeval picks up the baton and does the same for Utah, USA in the mid-1800s.

The stranger to town in American Primeval is Sara Rowell (Betty Gilpin). Along with her young son Devin (Preston Mota), she is crossing the country to reunite with Devin’s father in a place called Crooks Springs, and in need of a guide to escort them through this last, perilous part of their journey. The owner of the outpost they find themselves stranded in, Jim Bridger (Shea Whigham), makes explicitly clear how dangerous it will be – the terrain is mountainous and difficult enough to cross on its own, without the additional menace of the warring factions trying to control the land. The US Army, Native Americans, pioneers and Mormon militia all believe they have a God-given right to the land, and will kill anyone who finds themselves on their hallowed turf.

Jim introduces Sara to recluse wild man Isaac Reed (Taylor Kitsch) – a white man who is experienced in the ways of the local Native American tribe, the Shoshone – to act as her guide. Isaac monosyllabically refuses the position, leaving Sara with the only other option of begging a group of Mormons who are travelling to Salt Lake City to let her join their group. While youthful leader of the group, Jacob Pratt (Dane DeHaan), is reluctant, his outspoken wife Abish (Saura Lightfoot-Leon)  prevails on his Godly duties, and Sara and Devin join their wagons as they head out west.

On the road, Devin soon discovers they have a stowaway, a young, tongueless Native girl, Two Moons (a hauntingly powerful turn by Shawnee Pourier) who has run away from her tribe after stabbing her abuser. She is Shoshone, one of several local tribes being repeatedly moved on by the ever increasing land grab by Utah’s Governor Brigham Young (Kim Coates), also the leader of the Latter Day Saints church.

While Sara and Devin are fictional, Brigham Young was a real historical figure, and American Primeval is centered around the very real Mountain Meadows Massacre – the murder of 120 settlers in a wagon train by the Mormon Militia, who disguised themselves as Pioute nation, whom they had hired as mercenaries to assist in the siege. This mass murder would be one of the key incidents in the Utah War – a battle that erupted between the Mormon Militia, led by Gov Young, and the US Government, over power and autonomy in the region. It’s a part of American history I imagine most Brits are oblivious to, and here it acts as the pivotal moment which changes all of the character’s lives.

The massacre itself is one of the most polished, powerful,and stunningly choreographed action sequences I’ve ever seen. From the whizzing arrows continually crisscrossing the screen to the ox running through the wagon Sara and Devin hide under, it’s a breathtaking ride, with so many significant plot points peppered casually throughout. Two Moons, Sara and Devin escape the attack – aided by Isaac Reed, who has been watching from afar – with the Mormon militia hot on their trail, desperate to leave no witnesses to the siege alive.

Though only six episodes, it is crammed with story – from the half-scalped Jacob Pratt’s descent into madness as he searches for his bride Abish, to the journal diaries of helpless US Army Captain Edmund Dellinger (Lucas Neff) who finds the world running away with him as he tries to keep the law of the land – though it never feels overstuffed. Although, it could be said the bounty hunters who end up on Sara’s trail (as it turns out she is a rich woman wanted for murder) may be an unnecessary addition to the obstacles Sara faces. The elements, wolves, insane French-settlers, and murderous Mormons are enough for the found-family of Sara, Devin, Two Moons and Isaac to battle as they try to reach Crooks Springs.

Isaac Reed is a clear Joel Miller/Daryl Dixon archetype – a gruff, violent, tortured woodsman desperately trying to detach himself from humanity, but betrayed by his heart and morals – but the sharp writing, and underplayed, hunted emotion depicted by Taylor Kitsch elevates him above a simple trope. He is joined in the “good guy” stakes by Jim Bridger, a laid-back businessman with a twinkle in his eye, and a handshake for everyone, who, too, is under the cosh of the Mormon Governor and his plans for supremacy.

Under another showrunner, these men would be our central characters, but creator Mark L Smith (The Revenant, Twisters) diverts from the “Western” tropes and centres the story around the 3 women. It is the strength, humanity and resilience of Sara, Abish and Two Moons that carry us through the perfectly paced 6 episodes, and it’s their lives we become invested in, as they save themselves and each other. Betty Gilpin is magnificently captivating as the secretive, determined, and fierce mother, Sara, and shares incredible chemistry with her on-screen partners. The growing warmth between Sara and Isaac, as they begin to rely on each other, is engrossing, and the moments when they reveal the titbits of their pasts like shared morsels of food, are powerfly moving. Their relationship creates a satisfying emotional arc which warms the often desolate depiction of human nature.

Whilst Sara evades capture, Abish’s captivity is the other central story which weaves us through the Utah landscape. Surviving the massacre as a prize for the Piaute mercenaries, she ends up amongst the Shoshone people, when she is taken by warrior Red Feather (Derek Hinkey). Saura Lightfoot-Leon beautifully depicts Abish’s defiant, unbent spirit as Abish begins to realise the true, warm nature of the people she had been led to believe were savages. She works wonderfully as an audience proxy, bringing an intellectual, brave voice into the religious melee. It seems as though Abish, above all of the men, Native or white, is the only one to understand the futility of their religious fervour. As she says to Red Feather when he insists his gods tell him to kill the white men, “Whites believe their god tells them to kill you. Perhaps the gods are playing a game with all of us”. It’s a line which feels incredibly prescient and conveys just how much the world in American Primeval resembles our own, just more out in the open – something which is echoed in the character of Gov Young.

Kim Coates, often shot from below highlighting his untempered ego, inhabits the slick, duplicitous Gov Young with ease, capturing the modern evangelical preacher/American right-wing politician forerunner depressingly well. And Young’s successes certainly leave a nasty taste in the mouth, particularly this week. 

American Primeval is explicitly brutal and bleak, particularly in the stories of Abish’s husband Jacob – who descends into madness after a partial scalping, as he searches for his wife, Abish and becomes aware about the truth of his Mormon compatriots; and Captain Dellinger, abandoned in a chain of command he knows are using him as pawn. However, the interweaving of the many points of view, and the prevailing strength and power of the central female characters, prevent the limited series from feeling too nihilistic. The series tells a breathless, engaging and spirited story, which takes its cues from several classics. There are elements of Apocalypto, Last of the Mohicans and Deadwood in its depiction of the violent wrestling of changing times and changing rule in the West, though perhaps its spirit most closely resembles one of the greatest westerns of all time, Once Upon a Time in the West. It feels very much that the opening scene of Sara and Devin waiting at a train station for a man, in the middle of the dusty nowhere, is echoing the infamous opening sequence of Sergio Leone’s classic, starring Charles Bronsan and Henry Fonda. And there is a character death which, too, feels a lot like a homage to a character death in Once Upon a Time in the West, with similar beats and positioning.

Certainly, Mark L Smith has managed to create his own new classic, no matter where the inspiration came from. American Primeval is a compelling look at the corrupt power of the religious right of the country’s past, and a mirror to its present. Yet it never takes its foot from the pedal of driving home the vitality of love (mother for son, husband for wife, soldier for his people), reminding us that the human spirit will inevitably find a way to break through the ice of cruelty, no matter the tyrant. 

American Primeval is available now on Netflix 

Dawn Glen

Dawn Glen

22/01/2025

Scottish TV obsessive, who has been writing about TV since she sent a letter to Playschool and tracked Neighbours ratings. Co-creator of The Ship Yard, devoted to all slow-burn relationships - an all-consuming passion, especially in Britcoms. Wants to be Victoria Wood when she grows up.

Tags:

Follow us:

Our Latest Posts:

Saturday 7th – Friday 13th November 2026

Saturday 7th – Friday 13th November 2026

PICKS OF THE WEEK Blue Planet III Saturday 8th November BBC One Gone Fishing with Mortimer & Whitehouse Sunday 8th November BBC Two Pierre *Final Episode* Monday...

Monday 2nd – Friday 6th November 2026

Monday 2nd – Friday 6th November 2026

PICKS OF THE WEEK Saturday Night Live UK Saturday 31st October Sky One Gone Fishing with Mortimer & Whitehouse Sunday 1st November BBC Two Pierre Monday 2nd...

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Pin It on Pinterest