Doctor Who: The Star Beast review – A return to form?

by | Nov 25, 2023 | All, Reviews

Warning: Explicit, in-depth spoilers for The Star Beast

15 years ago, Donna Noble (Catherine Tate) forgot the Doctor (David Tennant). If she were ever to remember him, she would die, and so the Doctor moved on and Catherine Tate left the show. Two years later, David Tennant’s Doctor regenerated and Russell T. Davies handed the title of showrunner over. Now, 13 years on from that, all three are back for the 60th anniversary. But times have changed. In the years since the trio departed, there have been three doctors, two showrunners, eight companions, countless new writers, directors, a new composer, the list goes on. Doctor Who has moved on from 2008, and RTD has the monumental task of looking back on the show and its long history without falling into the trap of just reliving it entirely.

It’s no small task, and RTD delivers with some stellar writing. The Fourteenth Doctor isn’t just the tenth incarnation again, although he’s certainly strongly influenced by him. He runs around shouting allons-y and takes everything way too seriously, but he’s also a lot more open with his emotions, something learned throughout the tenures of both Matt Smith and Peter Capaldi’s doctors. A lot of his mannerisms are adopted from Jodie Whittaker’s incarnation, in the way he scrunches up his face and bounds around the place like an excitable puppy. David Tennant handles it with his ease, he understands the task he has in playing a doctor that may look like his own but no longer is, and it makes for an incarnation deserving of the unique numbering.

Doctor Who 60th Anniversary Specials,25-11-2023,The Star Beast, The Doctor (David Tennant) Rose (Yasmin Finney) Shaun Temple (Karl Collins) Sylvia Noble (Jacqueline King) Donna Noble (Catherine Tate) and The Meep, Alistair Heap

Another big return to Doctor Who is Murray Gold, composing for the series for the first time since Peter Capaldi’s regeneration in Twice Upon A Time  in 2017. His music here is stellar as always, but it’s new too. Queiter yet still playful, the first track of the episode, a whimsical tune as the Doctor leaves the tardis, while he still manages to hit harder with the sadder scenes. The music isn’t as extravagant as it was in the first four seasons when he was with RTD, but it’s just as great as it ever was.

Also returning from Twice Upon a Time is director Rachel Talalay, who makes excellent use of the new, expanded budget of the show. Doctor Who is looking beautiful and fresh for its 60th, with wide sweeping shots that really capture the vast enormity of what the show actually is. The aliens are a great mix of CGI and practical, looking the best they ever have on the show. It’s a clear new visual direction that works stunningly well.

Doctor Who 60th Anniversary Specials,25-11-2023,The Star Beast,1,Picture Shows: Shirley (Ruth Madeley), The Doctor (David Tennant) and Donna Noble (Catherine Tate),BBC Studios 2023,Alistair Heap

Alongside the old, we also get the new. We’re introduced to a new UNIT operative, Shirley Anne Bingham (Ruth Madeley), who’s in charge of the task force sent to investigate a ship that crashes early in the episode’s runtime. She’s an intriguing character, and though we don’t get to see much of her here, I look forward to her inclusion in later episodes. The Doctor’s trusty Sonic Screwdriver also gets an upgrade, now being able to summon a holographic screen he can look at data on as well as draw force fields in the air. They’re cool new additions that seamlessly edge into the show’s sci-fi element while not feeling too over the top.

David Tennant and Catherine Tate are still as much The Doctor and Donna as they ever were, an indomitable duo that just click together as easily as jam and toast. Even with Donna not remembering the Doctor there’s immediate chemistry between the two, Donna’s no-nonsense banter easily bouncing off the Doctor’s naturally chaotic state and making for some fun early scenes where she doesn’t know who he is and he has to hide it. Donna yelling “WE’VE GOT A BLOODY MARTIAN IN THE SHED” as new alien The Meep (voiced by Miriam Margoyles) enters the picture while her mum, Sylvia (Jacqueline King) desperately tries to stop the Doctor from entering the house through the front door is an immediate comedy classic in a long line of humorous Doctor Who scenes.

The first of the three specials, The Sea Beast is a tightly written and fast-paced story that helps to reintroduce us to the Doctor and Donna. When it’s eventually revealed that The Meep is a genocidal monster who just wants to kill, and the Wrarth warriors hunting it down are intergalactic police (which should come as no surprise to hardcore fans, as that particular storyline is lifted from the 1980s Doctor Who Magazine comic of the same name as the episode), the Doctor and Donna fall into an easy rhythm with Donna easily following the Doctor into the Meeps spaceship, if only in order to help him save her daughter.

There we get a beautiful scene where the Doctor has to make Donna remember him in order to save the world. It’s incredibly touching, heartfelt and agonising. It’s a moment fifteen years in the making, something the Doctor has been running from for so long. And now he has to say goodbye to her and let her go. For one brilliant, shining moment, Donna is back. She remembers the Doctor, she remembers everything, and she will give up her life for her daughter. At the end of it all, she falls into the Doctor’s arms, dying.

One of RTD’s strongest assets, however, was always his ability to weave domestic situations and storylines into the over-the-top alien adventures that the series thrives on. I’ve hinted at this with Donna jumping into the spaceship to save her daughter, and it’s ultimately this aspect which saves her life. In the episode, we’re introduced to her new family with her husband, Shaun Temple (Karl Collins) and his daughter Rose Noble (Yasmin Finney). Immediately they’re a close-knit unit- Rose is a bit of a social misfit due to being transgender but Donna is fiercely protective of her. She may not always get it right but she tries her hardest, and Donna’s love for her daughter is evident. Early on there’s a scene where Sylvia accidentally messes up Rose’s pronouns and you can tell she regrets it, but it isn’t an inherently bad thing and it’s incredibly realistic. It’s one of my favourite scenes in the episode, and possibly in the show to date. When I first came out to my sister, she made mistakes like that constantly, but she was still trying just as much as Sylvia does and it’s a little spark of humanity that hasn’t been present in the show since RTDs first era, arguably. While, without a doubt, the past two eras did tackle topics like that in ways of varying success, RTD does it with such a down to earth approach that it feels unlike anything else.

Rose’s identity is a big driving point in the main plot too. When Donna eventually does remember the Doctor, it’s revealed that she can now live longer through the metacrisis because of Rose. The metacrisis is now split between Donna and Rose, as Rose is her child and has inherited her genes. The Doctordonna, born from the metacrisis, is made up of a man and a woman, and now there’s a third component. Donna’s final words before losing her memory, binary binary binary. And her daughter, nonbinary, a third component, just as real and just as brilliant as anyone else. It’s a beautifully sweet moment that sets forth a mission for Doctor Who that it has always had- to keep progressing. To keep pushing boundaries and loving everyone.

It’s not perfect. Some of the writing around Rose is a little bit forced, like an early scene where the Doctor refers to The Meep as “he” and Rose responds with “did you just assume pronouns?” However, it comes across more like the “cool” uncle making jokes about nonbinary samurai to their genderqueer relatives than anything born of ignorance. It’s the kind of dialogue that is both cringy and endearing simultaneously.

RTD’s final gift to the future, however, is the new TARDIS interior. A new TARDIS is always a big event, and this might be one of the best ones yet. It harkens back to the classic era, with multiple white round lights on the wall (except these ones change colour), while feeling bigger and more spacious than ever. It sports sleek white and grey walkways and ramps, lifts and a coffee machine. It might be one of my favourites yet, as it feels completely alien yet completely like the Doctor. It’s an entrancing new beginning to the start of a new era of Doctor Who.

But it really only is the beginning, as Donna spills her coffee on the Tardis, breaks the console and they’re whisked away on an unknown adventure as the 60th anniversary resumes next week with Wild Blue Yonder at 6:30 PM on BBC One

Tyler Murray

Tyler Murray

25/11/2023

A lover of stories in any format, TV included. Dramas, comedies and thrillers find themselves in my top 3 genres to watch, but I am known to be a not so secret sap for romance too.

Tags:

Follow us:

Our Latest Posts:

Saturday 7th – Friday 13th November 2026

Saturday 7th – Friday 13th November 2026

PICKS OF THE WEEK Blue Planet III Saturday 8th November BBC One Gone Fishing with Mortimer & Whitehouse Sunday 8th November BBC Two Pierre *Final Episode* Monday...

Monday 2nd – Friday 6th November 2026

Monday 2nd – Friday 6th November 2026

PICKS OF THE WEEK Saturday Night Live UK Saturday 31st October Sky One Gone Fishing with Mortimer & Whitehouse Sunday 1st November BBC Two Pierre Monday 2nd...

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Pin It on Pinterest