REVIEW: Ordeal by Innocence – Does BBC One’s latest Agatha Christie adaptation deliver?

by | Apr 1, 2018 | All, Reviews

Agatha Christie’s murder mysteries are an international literary language; translated, loved and understood the world over. You know there’s going to be a big stately home, a cast of shifty upper-class characters, a few red herrings and a satisfyingly complicated conclusion. It’ll all hinge on the silver sugar tongs, a classified advert in the Times or the colour of the front door which you knew from the start but discounted as an inconsequential detail. It’s clever, gratifying and reassuring all in one shot. For a real-life example, please see me and Mr H on holiday in Turkey in 2014. We were, I’m ashamed to admit, battered out of our skulls on local raki and dealing with a day-long hangover in a hotel room easily as hot as the surface of the sun. What could be more soothing to the addled brain than finding Poirot dubbed into Turkish with English subtitles? In no small part thanks to Hercule we consoled the little grey cells that hadn’t been murdered by alcohol.

Ordeal by Innocence, the Easter Sunday BBC1 drama, is not your Turkish holiday Agatha Christie adaptation. There’s nothing soothing about this production. From the off it’s clear we’re in a nightmarish gothic horror. Producer and writer Sarah Phelps brings us a sharper, nastier, distilled version of And Then There Were None, her tremendous Christie adaptation from 2015. “Nine elaborate murders based on an extremely dodgy nursery rhyme that drive a young woman to suicide in a mansion on a deserted island is not really terrifying enough. Let’s kick it up a notch guys!”

Given the much-publicised production trouble we’re lucky to be able to see it at all. It was due to be the BBC1 Christmas drama centrepiece but had to be recast and reshot quickly with Christian Cooke as son Mickey instead of Ed Westwick, as Ed faces allegations of historic sexual abuse. In 2018, especially on a production with two women at the helm, going ahead with the original version would have been unconscionable. But honestly, if you spend more than 30 seconds looking for the join then I feel bad for you. The story is far more gripping than just material for speccy nitpickers. Although even thinking about how complicated the logistics must have been make me want to give the director Sandra Goldbacher and her crew a standing ovation. As the reshoot took place in winter the on-site editing team were kept busy cutting icy breath from scenes that were meant to be taking place in August. Phenomenal work!

The opening two minutes are a whirlwind of death and gothic fantasy ducking in and out of a timeline and weaving events of years and years together in a jarring montage. The action (and boy, is there a lot of it) centres on the wealthy Argyll family. Mum Rachel (Anna Chancellor) and Dad Leo (Bill Nighy in a rare TV role) have adopted a vast family of fairly disturbed orphans from all different counties and backgrounds. Having grown up with a dominating bullying matriarch who insists on projecting the perfect vision of family life at all times, is it any wonder she ends up bashed on the head, dead in a pool of blood in her own home? All I’m saying is watch out Brad and Angelina.

We don’t get much help in actually unravelling the story until over 17 minutes in when we finally get our first real conversation. We begin to iron out the confusion 18 months after Rachel’s murder. Her son Jack (Anthony Boyle) was convicted of the killing but protested his innocence to the end. And his end was final. Someone murdered him in prison before his trial. He’s the guy in the coffin we see in the initial montage, at the Victorian style funeral where I’m guessing the Addams family are about to make their entrance – cara mia! A twitchy stranger calling himself Dr Arthur Calgary (Luke Treadaway) turns up to provide Jack’s alibi on the same weekend as Leo is getting remarried to scheming secretary Gwenda (Alice Eve). We’ve not even got to the Buck’s fizz and it’s all kicking off already.

Despite the dizzying speed the camera lingers slow and sensual on the most gruesome details. Housekeeper Kirsten (Morven Christie) listens to the news on the radio about the atomic threat and nuclear fallout (protect and survive guys – hide under a table and we’ll all be fine!) as she guts a dead-eyed fish. We linger over the dark blood drip-drip-dripping into a bowl. Every item, ever person, in the house is a sinister threat and the camerawork and staging makes it all so brilliantly vivid.

A quick word to break up the tension about the fantastic casting, particularly Luke Treadaway supposedly a scatterbrained scientist, but clearly a hot mess of a person and just as troubled as the family. Do we buy his story about being away at the North pole and missing his chance to exonerate Jack in time or does he have a prison tan as the perfectly acidic and probably perceptive son-in-law Philip (Matthew Goode) suspects? Bill Nighy is doing his excellent angry and baffled routine, and Eleanor Tomlinson is almost unrecognisable as desperate-to-please daughter Mary; a character who couldn’t be more dissimilar to the capable and crusading Demelza Poldark.

So this is the deal – if poor crazy Jack was innocent after all, Rachel’s killer is still free, and at large in the family home. At this point, there’s so much venom and barely-constrained rage whirling about the place it could have been any or all of them. The attention to detail is fascinating but the mood, the tensions and the direction means it’s a very unsettling watch. It’s as confusing and disorientating as a Turkish raki hangover, so go into it with a clear head, an attentive attitude and do pause it for a cup of tea if it all gets too much. It’s far too frightening to watch it in the dark. You have been warned.

Contributed by Sarah Kennedy

Ordeal by Innocence continues next Sunday on BBC One at 9pm 

Sarah Kennedy

Sarah Kennedy


Birmingham-based square-eyed TV obsessive. Loves oddball British comedy, bleak Scandi murders, and fiendish quiz shows in equal measure. Too old to watch telly on my phone. Natural habitat: on the sofa. Always on the lookout for the next great subtitled mega-hit.


Follow us:

Our Latest Posts:

351: 2022: The year so far.

351: 2022: The year so far.

Luke joins Matt to look at the first seven months of the year including discussions on Sherwood, Barry and The Responder. Listen to "# 351: 2022: The mid-year report"...

Borgen proves TV revivals can work.

Borgen proves TV revivals can work.

Borgen is the best political series on television. It's not an area television drama dabbles in that often. There's the original House of Cards and the Netflix version...


Submit a Comment