Rian Johnson’s Poker Face revels in a much loved TV format and reminds us how much fun it can be.

by | May 19, 2023 | All, Reviews

When director Rian Johnson’s (Knives Out, Knives Out: Glass Onion) wife became friends with Natasha Lyonne (Russian Doll, Orange is the New Black) he was jealous. Lyonne is effortlessly cool and interesting and he wanted to be her friend too. In an interview to promote their new series Poker Face, which aired earlier this year in the US, Johnson said the pair eventually bonded over their love of Columbo. An admirer of her Netflix series Russian Doll, Johnson always thought Lyonne had a touch of Peter Falk’s iconic Columbo. The long coat she wore for the duration of the series is very reminiscent of Falk’s and her interesting speech pattern and cadence too. Johnson had been wanting to bring a Columbo-type show back to TV for some time, and with Lyonne, he’d found his lead.

Crime drama has always been a staple of television but has fallen out of favour over time in the US. With cable networks and streaming platforms far keener on long-form storytelling like Breaking Bad, The Americans, and Succession. But Johnson’s movie Knives Out, which focused on a murder within a wealthy family solved by the mysterious and meticulous investigator Benoit Blanc (Daniel Craig) proved a hit at a time when cinema-goers appear only interested in big-budget franchises. The fact Netflix lured Johnson for two sequels proves what a megahit the film was and that the appetite was there for what had been viewed as ‘old school’ storytelling.

Poker Face is episodic with Jonhnson keen that the show not be binged. It’s the antithesis of the binge model, harking back to a time when things were satisfactorily tied up at the end episode but you come back because you enjoy the way the story is told and the characters involved. Here in the UK broadcasters still lean heavily on the format with Death in Paradise, Vera, Grace, and Silent Witness not showing any signs of coming to an end.  Even though I’m familiar with all of the shows I’ve listed there, Poker Face still feels like a great combination between a breath of fresh air and putting on a reliable pair of comfy shoes. A case of the week show (even though Sky has decided to make the whole season available which somewhat misses the idea behind the show) that follows Lyonne’s Charlie Cale as she travels across the US finding work in various places but using her unique gift of calling bulls**t whenever someone tries to lie to her. It’s a clever premise because it doesn’t rely on police tropes. Charlie isn’t police, she’s an ordinary woman with a first-class bulls**t detector that never fails her. It’s a skill even she can’t explain. When a man drops his elderly uncle at a retirement village she’s working in, she knows immediately that the man isn’t his nephew and the pair don’t have any family links at all, but she can’t explain how she knows. She can just tell when someone is lying to her.

Like Columbo, it sometimes takes a while for Charlie to appear on the scene, with Johnson (who directs and writes some episodes) and his team using the first portion of the episode to explore the key characters Charlie will be in contact with and even the inciting incident before we flash back to see how Charlie fits into the story. It says a lot about Natasha Lyonne’s performance that I found myself desperate to see her each time I had to wait. There are some similarities between Charlie and her Russian Doll character Nadia. Both are incredibly observant, detail-orientated, and curious, but where Nadia was slightly miserable and wary of others, Charlie is liked and makes friends everywhere she goes and Natasha Lyonne is incredibly good in the role.

At the start of the series, Charlie is working as a cocktail waitress at a Nevada Casino after falling foul of the wrong people, using her special skill to become an unbeatable poker player. But as is the case with these kinds of shows, trouble inevitably keeps finding her, always in the form of a murder that only she can solve, because she knows that the killer is full of it. She’s on the run from her boss after she figures out he’s behind the death of one of her closest friends at the casino. The need for somewhere to lay low sees Charlie turn up at a number of varied locations and take on different jobs. She’s a roadie for a one-hit-wonder heavy metal band where Chloë Sevigny is the aging frontwoman desperate for a comeback. She works at a Texas BBQ where an awful murder takes place, and at a retirement village where two of the residents are hiding a big secret. Each of the different locations makes each episode feel fresh and distinctive. Even the settings I was initially less interested in like when Charlie works at a go-kart track where two warring families are fighting for the championship or when she works with a special effects artist, turned out to be as exciting and engaging as the ones I’d loved from the start.

The first episode is very much a set-up episode explaining Charlie’s gift, who she is, and how she ends up on the run.  The second, ‘The Night Shift’ is a perfectly crafted episode that sees Charlie drawn into the mystery surrounding the death of a local when she stops for petrol in New Mexico. It’s a show that revels in its format, where every innoxious conversation could prove vital in unraveling the mystery or Charlie spotting the lie. The central performance is so full of charm and nuance and the mysteries are so intricately plotted that I never tired of watching it. It’s not a show that needs to be consumed in the way the streaming age has convinced us we need to watch television, instead, it’s fun to catch up with Charlie in a new setting once a week. Johnson has spoken of his desire to make Poker Face a long-running series and Peacock has already given the show a second season, Poker Face proves that older formats still work, particularly with devotees of the genre behind the scenes making sure they feel relevant. It’s not setting out to reinvent the wheel or big the next big thing, but it does what it does in such expert fashion it’s impossible not to fall for it.

All episodes of Rian Johnson’s Poker Face starring Natasha Lyonne available from Friday 26 May exclusively on Sky Max and NOW

Luke Knowles

Luke Knowles

19/05/2023

Editor of the website and host of the podcast. A general TV obsessive. I've been running the site since 2008 and you can usually find me in front of the TV. My Favourite show of all time is Breaking Bad with Cracker coming a close second. I feel so passionately that television can change the world and I'm doing my little bit by running this site. You're Welcome!

Tags:

Follow us:

Our Latest Posts:

Saturday 7th – Friday 13th November 2026

Saturday 7th – Friday 13th November 2026

PICKS OF THE WEEK Blue Planet III Saturday 8th November BBC One Gone Fishing with Mortimer & Whitehouse Sunday 8th November BBC Two Pierre *Final Episode* Monday...

Monday 2nd – Friday 6th November 2026

Monday 2nd – Friday 6th November 2026

PICKS OF THE WEEK Saturday Night Live UK Saturday 31st October Sky One Gone Fishing with Mortimer & Whitehouse Sunday 1st November BBC Two Pierre Monday 2nd...

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Pin It on Pinterest