Task episode 4: The walls are closing in.

by | Sep 29, 2025 | All, Reviews

In episode 3 of Task, we were treated to a flashback to the day Tom (Mark Ruffalo), his wife, and their young daughter, Sara (Phoebe Fox), welcomed their new adopted children, Emily (Silvia Dionicio) and Ethan (Andrew Russel), into the family home for the first time. It’s the first time we’ve seen the family dynamic, with the sun streaming through the kitchen and cake and balloons everywhere, as the entire family is happy to start an exciting new chapter. It’s possibly the last time that house was full of sun and happiness. Ethan’s mental health issues turned Tom’s wife into a virtual recluse, as she fought desperately to get him the help he needed. It turned mother against daughter and sister against sister, with Tom stuck in the middle. Sara describes living with Ethan as a ‘war zone’. The atmosphere in the house must have been unbearable. It’s completely understandable that Emily, as Ethan’s older sister, would feel protective of her brother. She’d grown up with him and had a past with him long before they were taken in by the Brandis family. It’s also completely understandable that as their ‘blood daughter’, Sara would feel nothing but resentment and anger towards the ‘brother’ who turned her mother into someone who could barely leave the house and someone who would die at the hands of the person she was trying to help. It’s an impossible situation where everyone is right to have the feelings they do, and it lingers over everything Tom does within the task force.

In episode 4, we get another flashback. This time, it’s Robbie’s (Tom Pelphrey) life before his beloved brother Billy was beaten to death by Jayson (Sam Keeley) and the rest of the Dark Harts gang. The dynamic here isn’t as warm as the one in the Brandis house, but it does demonstrate how close the two brothers were and explains why Robbie feels he needs to risk everything to bring the Dark Harts down and get revenge on Jayson.  We know now that the mysterious texter, telling Robbie and Cliff (Raúl Castillo) which of the trap houses to hit, is Jayson’s girlfriend Eryn (Margarita Levieva) whom Billy was in love with before his death. It’s a risk for Eyrn, who is still with Jayson, to be in contact with Robbie, let alone helping him plot behind his back. The fact that Cliff and Robbie have ended up unwittingly holding a sweet 7-year-old boy hostage is still sending Cliff spiralling, but Robbie remains calm, fixated on bringing Jayson down, taking his money and using that to start a new life with Maeve (Emilia Jones) and the kids in Canada. Maeve, ever the sensible one, reminds Robbie he hasn’t factored in schooling, doctors, or where they’re actually going to live. She also issues an ultimatum; either he turns Sam in or she will.

The task force is finally gelling after some awkward missteps. They have intel that Cliff (Robbie up until this point hasn’t been connected to things) has the bag of drugs and will drop it off to The Dark Harts and collect the money. The task force are the ones pulling the strings: texting Cliff from an old associate’s phone to arrange everything. This should give Tom some pause for thought, as it means he’s one step closer to securing Sam safely, but it’s hard to keep focused on the job at hand when he realises one of his new team might be passing on information to the Dark Harts, who always seem one step ahead of whatever the team are planning to do. It’s hard to believe, especially when you consider the suspects. Aleah (Thuso Mbedu), who last week bravely shared her experience of sexual assault and coercive control to get the girlfriend of one of Cliff’s associates to confess she knew him. Anthony Grasso (Fabien Frankel) is braggadocios, but it’s hard to picture him sabotaging the first big break he has had.  Which leaves loveable Lizzie (Alison Oliver), who seems an even less likely candidate to be the mole unless she was passing information along to Gwen Stefani or Akon (yes, The Sweet Escape is stuck in my head). The blossoming relationship between Lizzie and Grasso appears genuinely sweet and adds a new layer to the show, away from the darkness that surrounds Robbie and Tom. A more interesting angle for who is talking to the Dark Harts and keeping them abreast of the task forces’ movements could be Tom’s boss, Kathleen (Martha Plimpton). We know she’s been forced into retirement. Is she the mole? I hope so, if only because it will mean Martha Plimpton will get more screen time.

On paper, the stories being told here could feel generic, but creator and writer Brad Ingelsby never takes the easy route. I’ve spoken before about how every new drama has to be a thriller, and I tire of the genre quickly. The reason I tend to dismiss thrillers, particularly the ones the BBC, ITV, and 5 are doling out week after week, is that they frequently forget that for any drama to be compelling, the characters need to be interesting. Too often, thrillers rely on  an intriguing mystery as enough to sustain viewers, and characters feel paper-thin as a result. Brad Ingelbsy crafts his shows (Mare of Easttown and now Task) from a different standpoint. Grounding them in settings that have a deep history, he always remembers that the characters drive the story rather than the mysteries at the centre of the plot. In a lesser drama, Robbie would be a clichéd-wronged person, desperate for revenge, but here, he’s someone still deep in grief, trying the only way he can think of to get some degree of closure and better the lives of his children. In a tender scene, he coaxes his daughter, Harper (Kennedy Moyer), to dance with him in their kitchen. It’s a genuinely sweet moment that reminds you that Robbie is a loving father, that his children have a good bond with him, but it is broken when Harper tells him she can sense something wrong in the house and that she’d already put the money he had given her for the upcoming father-daughter dance back in his wallet. It’s a moment that catches you by surprise, how something so tender can quickly turn bleak again, and a reminder that Robbie’s children aren’t immune to his actions.

As the episode draws to a close, it really feels like the walls are closing in. The sting operation the Task Force had planned goes nowhere, but the Dark Harts run Cliff off the road, bringing him to their hideout and suffocating him to death. Another life that Robbie will soon have on his conscience. Though Robbie’s involvement hasn’t been known yet, it seems only a matter of time before they link the two co-workers to each other. Especially given the factt that the task force receives a copy of some CCTV which shows them for the first time that Sam is alive. At the same time, Perry (Jamie McShane), the real leader of The Dark Harts appears to be slowly putting the pieces together too. Realising Jayson’s involvement in Billy’s death and connecting the dots to Robbie or Maeve before the task force has them on their radar.

Task Continues Sunday on HBO and Monday on Sky Atlantic and NOW 

Luke Knowles

Luke Knowles

29/09/2025

Editor of the website and host of the podcast. A general TV obsessive. I've been running the site since 2008 and you can usually find me in front of the TV. My Favourite show of all time is Breaking Bad with Cracker coming a close second. I feel so passionately that television can change the world and I'm doing my little bit by running this site. You're Welcome!

Tags:

Follow us:

Our Latest Posts:

Saturday 7th – Friday 13th November 2026

Saturday 7th – Friday 13th November 2026

PICKS OF THE WEEK Blue Planet III Saturday 8th November BBC One Gone Fishing with Mortimer & Whitehouse Sunday 8th November BBC Two Pierre *Final Episode* Monday...

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Pin It on Pinterest