Deadwood, Sky One

by | Sep 21, 2004 | All, Reviews

What to say of you liked it

A contemporary adaptation of the legendary Wild West that doesn’t baulk at illuminating the coarse reality of a frontier prospecting town through both brutality and profanity.

What to say if you didn’t like it

A dreadfully derivative drama where if you condensed the scenes without bad language you would have just a five-minute vignette.

What was good about it?

• None of the protagonists are decent and good, merely varying degrees of an evil necessitated to survive in the, quite literally, cut-throat frontier town of Deadwood. From the legendary Wild Bill Hickok, who guns down a murder suspect on a hunch, to former marshal Seth Bullock who hands in his badge to move to Deadwood after personally hanging a criminal, to the malevolent Al Swearengen, the owner of the local bar who kills allies and enemies with equal delight.

• John Hawkes as Sol Star, Bullock’s sidekick who gets all the best lines and is a Sancho Panza to his boss’s Don Quixote.

• The drab costumes, that are either as muddy as Deadwood’s main thoroughfare, or as grey as the panelled, imposing buildings.

• The subtle way in which the social, and dramatic, class of the characters are conveyed. A huge moustache and clipped beard indicate the most powerful (Swearengen and Hickok); while a smaller moustache and beard point to the middle ranks (Bullock, Star and the wealthy but naïve Brom Garret); and a full unkempt beard designates the often expendable underlings (Swearengen’s apprentice Johnny Burns and his henchman

Dan Dority).

• The characters were introduced in an episodic manner that was easy to follow and transmitted their basic traits, whether it was Swearengen arranging to swindle Garret out of a fortune or Calamity Jane swearing at everyone and everything.

• Ian McShane as Al Swearengen whose eyes hardly move, and when they do so they prowl deliberately around his sockets like a tiger stalking its prey.

• Dan Dority looks like Bolton boss Sam Allardyce.

What was bad about it?

• In Al Swearengen’s first scene the dialogue about him being English seemed to have been inserted as much to explain away McShane’s accent, that rapidly vacillated

between English and American, as to add biographical colour.

• The bad language may have been realistic, but it was so accentuated and frequent that after 10 minutes it already seemed to be simply for effect. But after 20 minutes it had already exceeded an hour’s worth of Sopranos profanity, and by the three-quarter mark it would have made Millwall fans blush.

• While many roles were expertly introduced through plotting, there seemed a rather hackneyed need to display Swearengen’s evil whether through beating up a prostitute, ordering a henchman killed or taking an overtly racist attitude towards the Native Americans who controlled some of the gold laden land.

Series two

What to say if you liked it

The return of the most lucidly lifelike recreation of the Wild, Wild West.

What to say if you didn’t like it

A sordid little drama that hides behind the voluminous skirts of “realism” and “authenticity” to cheaply parade a scarcely-linked segue of gratuitous profanity, prurience and iniquity.

What was good about it?

• The opening titles sequence in which a horse runs free through Deadwood while attracting no attention from the residents who are engrossed by some 1877 vintage

of the Seven Sins, whether it’s gold prospecting, gunfights or prostitution.

• Ian McShane is magnetic as Al Swearengen and still has the easy capacity to impale other characters on the spiked barb of his gaze. And even though he is one of the most repellent caricatures on TV, his qualities as an anti-hero make him the most appealing draw over protagonist Seth.

• Timothy Olyphant as Seth Bullock, whose morose nature and convoluted private life award him the same, albeit more subtle, depth as Al.

• Re-establishing the lawlessness of Deadwood through an incident in which Harry the proprietor has threatened “Slippery” Dan with death if he comes in his bar after urinating on him. “Slippery” Dan sends in his oblivious pal “Bummer” Dan dressed in his clothes

leading Harry to shoot the unfortunate “Bummer” dead (“Isn’t getting pissed on a provocation?”). When Sheriff Bullock arrives he merely issues a warning for Harry and “Slippery” to watch it.

• Al and Seth’s fight after Al insults Seth’s lover Alma Garrett. They half-wrestled, half-punched each other until their grappling causes them to topple off the first floor balcony into the muddy thoroughfare. Seth starts to pummel Al until one of Al’s henchmen stuns him, while another shoots and wounds a pair of Seth’s allies. Al is only stopped from cutting Seth’s throat by the nervous intrusion of William, Seth’s nephew, on a stage coach.

• Women being referred to as though walking genitalia which helps characterise the odious misogyny of Al and his rival Cy Tolliver (Powers Boothe).

• The blurred shot through the dazed Seth’s eyes as he gazes on his “wife” and “son” after they arrive in Deadwood.

• The imaginative design of the sets and costumes which ensures the only primary and secondary colours occur mostly in natural things such as vegetation, fire and blood while the manmade stuff are painted only by differing shades of brown and grey.

• Some of the dialogue is exquisite, if a little gruesome. Cy Tolliver: “Don’t believe there’s no good women, until you’ve seen one with maggots in her eyes.”

What was bad about it?

• The lack of a heroic protagonist lessens the grip on the viewer as you begin to care less about what happens to even the most likeable characters. But giving Seth a conflict of duty and passion between his “wife” and “son”, his brother’s widow and son whom he must now care and his new love Alma Garrett for was a clever twist.

• The swearing seems to have gotten too tight a grip on the dialogue and identity of the show, and rather than embellishing the authenticity seems to be almost a character in itself. It can also encumber an exchange with such superfluous profanity as to numb the impact of the exchange. This was most keen in the banter that preceded Al and Seth’s scrap, as we still don’t have a clue exactly what Al said to get Seth so riled only that his tone made it sound very unpleasant.

Luke Knowles

Luke Knowles

21/09/2004

Editor of the website and host of the podcast. A general TV obsessive. I've been running the site since 2008 and you can usually find me in front of the TV. My Favourite show of all time is Breaking Bad with Cracker coming a close second. I feel so passionately that television can change the world and I'm doing my little bit by running this site. You're Welcome!

Tags:

Follow us:

Our Latest Posts:

Saturday 7th – Friday 13th November 2026

Saturday 7th – Friday 13th November 2026

PICKS OF THE WEEK Blue Planet III Saturday 8th November BBC One Gone Fishing with Mortimer & Whitehouse Sunday 8th November BBC Two Pierre *Final Episode* Monday...

Monday 2nd – Friday 6th November 2026

Monday 2nd – Friday 6th November 2026

PICKS OF THE WEEK Saturday Night Live UK Saturday 31st October Sky One Gone Fishing with Mortimer & Whitehouse Sunday 1st November BBC Two Pierre Monday 2nd...

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Pin It on Pinterest