It seems almost impossible that Severance creator Dan Erikson could live up to last season’s dramatic cliffhanger finale, and the standard set by the ground-breaking, outstanding episodes that have made up the bulk of this second season. Yet somehow, they have, and as is always the way with Severance, pushed those boundaries even further, as they tie the seasons thread together. And yes, they even managed to explain the goats.
We begin “Cold Harbor” in the birthing cabin where Devon (Jen Tullock) and Miss Cobel (Patricia Arquette) have brought Mark (Adam Scott), for them to be able to talk to his innie, and find out the truth about Mark’s not-as-dead-as-he-thought wife, Gemma (Dichen Lachman). In a clever storytelling device, innie and outie Mark take turns recording their side of a conversation on a video recorder, before stepping either into or out of the cabin, so that their opposite can watch and volley back their response.
Mark and his MDR colleagues used the Overtime Contingency last season, so desperate were they to communicate to their outies the suffering they were experiencing. But here we now have an easy route of conversation between the personas—yet what is revealed is anything but easy.
As the two Marks talk, the central moral quandary of Severance is fleshed out, and it’s as if Erickson has placed it on a coffee table as the Marks talk around it. It’s something I’ve found easy to forget, as I got lost in the plight of Mark Scout. What rights do the severed have? Do the innies have any kind of body autonomy? What happens when their outie never returns to the severed floor?
I, like I believe many other viewers, had cosily assumed that kind, sweet innie Mark would automatically want to rescue Gemma from Lumon’s clutches and take down the corporate overlord as soon as possible. But why would Mark S want to do that? Yes, he’s a good person, but what reason does he have to trust his outie? A man who sent him back to Lumon after the Overtime Contingency revealed the life his innie leads, and – more significantly – a man who was willing to create him in the first place.
There has – of course – been a focus on the evil of Lumon, their manipulation and control of those people in their employ, but even though Mark is grieving and vulnerable, we have to acknowledge he did willingly create a person who would exist purely to take on his menial and emotional labour, just so he wouldn’t feel pain for 8 hours a day. It really becomes clear that Mark Scout isn’t our protagonist, Mark S is, and it’s something that’s been hinted at by the more ignoble outie versions of the Severed employees we love.
Helena (Britt Lower) is the most obvious villainous version of her outie – a cold, abusive, ruthless version of the feisty, righteous and loving Helly. And our beloved Burt (Christopher Walken) – a gentle, romantic artist – was revealed to be a menacing hired goon in his outer life. Even sweet, loyal Dylan (Zach Cherry) was shown to be a negative, lazy, apathetic version of his MDR persona. While each has a valid reason to be making this massive mistake of being severed, it doesn’t take away the fact that they still did it. They were willing to bring this version of themselves into existence, without much thought about their creation’s life. It’s a massively topical issue – evil on a grand scale is only allowed to succeed by ordinary, decent people letting minor malevolence go because it makes their life easier.
Answering one of the big questions going into the finale, it becomes clear that despite the events of previous episodes, Reghabi’s (Karen Alridge) reintegration of Mark is not complete. And though Mark Scout reassures Mark S, that he will continue the process, innie Mark has no reason to trust this, or even to know if it did happen, how would it work? When innie Mark says he has only 2 years of memories, while outie Mark has 40, so how could he not be swallowed up by that avalanche of experience? A lightbulb came on for me about the morality and hopelessness of the situation Mark Scout has created.
Front-loading the episode with the existential questions is a brave move, but as the episode unravels it’s clear Erickson wanted to make sure the audience was on the same page, and thinking about the entire existence of the severed staff before going into the action portion of the episode. And action it certainly is, proving that despite Severance’s reputation as a slow-moving, cerebral show, it knows how to pull out the other stops when needed.
Woe, Frolic, Dread and Malice are not just the 4 tempers that Lumon’s founder Keir believed are the key pillars of human consciousness, they are also the emotions that Severance drags its audience through during the extended episode. While Woe permeates the opening scenes, we then turn to Dread and Malice as Helly and Mark S return to the MDR office, which has now taken a horror movie ambience with ominous darkness and a waxwork figure of Keir, spotlit and watching over Mark’s completion of the Cold Harbor file – an event so momentous, there’s already an extensive mural in the hallway depicting this achievement.

The explanation of Cold Harbor, given by Miss Cobel in the cabin to Mark S, fits in with the speculation of many (including myself) that he was “refining” the tempers of Gemma’s innies, and his importance is due to his emotional connection to her. We still don’t know why Gemma and Mark were chosen, and what the other MDR employees were doing, but we know that – for whatever reason – Gemma was able to be pushed further than any other test subject, and that Cold Harbor would be the 25th, record-breaking, innie created within Gemma’s mind. And once completed, marks the end of Mark Scout’s usefulness, and Gemma and Mark S’s existence.
Putting together the pieces from Miss Cobel’s past, and the awareness that Lumon were pushing each Gemma innie to see if the barriers broke with negative emotional pressure (fear of the dentist, hatred of writing thank you notes), it’s clear that cold, cruel Cobel belayed a softer interior. With her use of Miss Cassey, she was obviously testing the power of love, to see if that more positive emotion could break through the innie’s barriers – and secretly hoping it would.
It’s absolutely heartbreaking to see Gemma walk through the Cold Harbor test, a persona so close to the real Gemma that Lumon give her back her own clothes to wear. Making her take apart the crib we saw Mark losing it with in the flashback in “Chikhai Bardo”, alone in a sterile white room is the most astonishing cruelty that takes your breath away with its normalcy and malevolence, while Jame watches and encourages to see if Cold Harbor Gemma will crack and real Gemma’s pain and grief will break through. Michael Siberry’s genius as Jame, and his breathy, other worldly evilness truly takes the Malice to a whole new level.
But fear not, as it’s time for Frolic. Let it never be said that Severance doesn’t know how to sweep your feet from under you, and as Mark and Helly hold hands and accept their fate by completing Cold Harbor, Seth Milchik (Tramell Tillman) arrives and turns the terror into hilarity. Tramell Tillman snatches the Best Supporting Actor EMMY from John Turturro (who doesn’t appear in this episode, is he gone forever?), as he delivers a comedy double act with waxwork Keir (laced with moments of unscripted bitterness from the increasingly disenfranchised employee) before calling on the hitherto unknown department, Choreography and Merriment to celebrate Mark’s achievement. A sci-fi, horror drama which has one of its main “bad guys” lead a marching band, with some frankly fantastic dancing, but never loses its menace, is truly a special thing.

The bizarreness and chaos of the marching band provide the soundtrack and tempo of the crescendo of the episode, as Helly distracts Milchik, to allow Mark to escape and use Irving’s directions to take him to the testing floor where he can rescue Gemma. Edge-of-your-seat action thriller is not what you expect, but there is a feeling of the season one finale as everyone comes into their own to get Mark to Gemma. Helly gives a rousing speech to the C&M band about the evils of Lumon, to get them on side, while – just at the right moment – Dylan returns (his outie having refused his resignation, explaining that it gives him hope that wife Gretchen will eventually see in him what she sees in innie Dylan) to push a vending machine in front of the door holding Milchik back.
Mark’s ultimate fight with Mr Drummond (Dari Olafsson) is one of the most believably brutally raw, violent exchanges I have seen on screen, and the return of Gwendoline Christie (an actress whose appearance always makes me cheer, but more so here) as Lorne is a perfect punch in the air satisfying climax. (Lorne, it turns out, has been nurturing the goats to be entombed with each female “cherished” test subject when they are killed. Much to Lorne’s unhappiness).
As the episode draws to an end, we return again to the moral question from the start – one that is highlighted in Mr Drummond’s fate, as innie Mark only takes him hostage, but Mark Scout accidentally kills him as they swap consciousnesses. It’s a genius metaphor for the entire topic of Severance, the accidental damage and destruction the ones choosing to be severed create, and the literal blood on their hands compared to their innocent innies.

Mark Scout and Gemma are finally reunited as Mark rescues her from the testing floor, but it’s always been clear that there couldn’t be a happy ending for all. Innie Mark loves Helly, outie Mark loves Gemma. The visual spelling out of the dilemma, with Gemma behind the glass in the real world, and Helly at the end of the corridor, with Mark looking between them as the red alarm lights flash around them is a visually powerful apogee to all which has gone before. And as I said, it was clear innie Mark is our true protagonist, and it’s his own happy ending that he chooses, leaving Gemma to escape alone as he runs hand in hand through the corridors with Helly, in a very Hitchcock-esque end sequence.
It’s an almost impeccable ending to a season that has blown me, and most other reviewers, away. Erickson and Director Ben Stiller have shown an exemplary ability to finely play the audience with the right amount of exposition and mystery, and a true understanding of the human condition. Rarely has a show created so much debate, whilst simultaneously creating a unified audience experience. There is no drama so complex and carefully crafted, and no TV show which so embraces a complete aesthetic and world-building in the extreme.
It feels very much like this was a complete ending, but with a new showrunner announced, it seems unlikely it is, and for that we’re grateful. Despite the fact they now seem to have answered several of the central mysteries, there are still many questions remaining (who was Irving phoning?) and on the strength of season 2, Severance has plenty more corridors to run down.
All episodes of Severance are now streaming on AppleTV+.





0 Comments